The Best Easy Mac and Cheese Recipe

This macaroni and cheese recipe is incredibly easy and totally delicious – creamy and velvety, thanks to a heaping dose of pub cheese.

We LOVE pub cheese… it’s one of my favorite easy spreadable cheeses (like my knockout pimento cheese, which is a recipe everyone needs to try at least once!) – and in this recipe, we’re mixing it with shredded cheddar for the most unbelievably delicious mac and cheese.

If you love this recipe – be sure to check out our super easyBacon Ranch Chicken Mac and Cheese, too!

This recipe takes less than 20 minutes to make and is perfect for even beginner cooks – we hope your family loves it as much as we do!

We have a lot of readers on Ajpal with lots of questions about recipes, who have asked us to provide more information.

What Cheese To Use

For this recipe, we’re using creamy, rich pub cheese and tangy sharp cheddar for a delicious balance and over-the-top cheesy flavor your whole family will love.

Since this recipe is very simple, it is important to pick flavorful cheeses that will take this creamy pasta over the top!

What is Pub Cheese

Pub cheese is usually made from cheddar cheese, mixed with milk and cream, so it’s easy to spread.

Pub cheese is great spread on crackers – but it also gives an incredible creaminess to macaroni and cheese that you have to taste to believe!

What Pub Cheese to Pick

We picked plain sharp cheddar pub cheese for this recipe to keep the classic creamy Mac and cheese flavor – but you can pick any flavor pub cheese you’d like.

You can change the flavor of your macaroni and cheese easily by grabbing different flavors of pub cheese – from bacon to chive, to port, or even jalapeno!

You can be as creative as you’d like with the type of beer cheese you grab.

What Cheddar Cheese for Mac and Cheese

Opt for sharp or extra sharp cheese for extra tangy flavor – or grab mild if your family prefers a more mellow cheese flavor.

This recipe works best with cheddar cheese that is freshly shredded – not the pre-shredded cheese from bags.

While it is easier to reach for pre-shredded cheeses, they are often treated with anti-clumping preservatives which can change how they melt – so shredding your own cheese fresh is the best option.

Tips To Perfect Creamy Mac and Cheese

This mac and cheese is super simple and easy to make – even for beginner cooks – but we have a couple of easy tips to make this recipe even easier, and to help you make it perfectly, every time.

Make A Roux

Making a roux (a browned butter and flour mixture) is an essential part of this recipe – it is a super simple step, but brings so much flavor.

Don’t rush your recipe or skip the roux – it helps make your macaroni and cheese thicker, with a nuttier, richer taste.

What to Serve With Mac and Cheese

Mac and cheese goes with just about everything – it is quick to whip up, and it goes with all kinds of delicious dinners.

We’re sharing our favorite sides with mac aand cheese that are simple, quick, and full of flavor:

• 10 Minute Broccolini Recipe
• Perfect Sauteed Mushrooms
• Garlic Herb Butter Baked Pork Loin and Potatoes
• The Best Oven Roasted Turkey Breast Recipe

And if you’d like to top your mac and cheese with delicious meats, please check out our favorites below:

• Perfect Grilled Chicken Breasts
• The Best Air Fryer Steaks
• The Best Grilled Pork Tenderloin
• The Best Easy Broiled Lobster Tails Recipe
• The Best One Pot Lemon Garlic Butter Shrimp Recipe Ever

Mac and Cheese Without Mustard

This recipe includes mustard power as a part of the spice mixture – but if you’re avoiding mustard (or you’re allergic to mustard, like me!), I have a few tips below on other ways to get a rich flavor in your mac and cheese without the mustard.

Turmeric

You can use turmeric at a 1:1 ratio instead of mustard – it gives you the same yellow color and a similar earthy richness, but a less spicy kick than mustard.

Horseradish

Horseradish is spicier than mustard, so you won’t want to make a 1:1 substitution – use half or slightly less than half the amount of horseradish you would mustard powder.

Wasabi

Wasabi is spicier than mustard, but gives a delicious tangy twist to this mac and cheese.

If using wasabi powder in macaroni and cheese, use half the amount of mustard powder you would add to the recipe.

Be very careful when substituting wasabi if you have a mustard allergy (like me) – some wasabis are prepared with ground mustard.

Recipe FAQ’s

Pub cheese is usually found near the specialty cheeses. Make sure to grab sharp cheddar, and not another flavor, if you want a classic macaroni and cheese flavor.

Penne, cavatappi, medium shells are great pasta alternatives for this recipe.

Any spreadable cheese works – be sure to pick a flavor you really love, since this recipe is very simple and doesn’t have many ingredients.

Share on Facebook

Pin this now to find it later

Ajpal Favorites

If you love this easy recipe, be sure to check out our reader favorites!

These tried and true classics are always a huge hit with our family and our readers families!